Leftist candidate Zohran Mamdani is making audacious claims about the future of New York City’s policing, insisting that if he becomes mayor, all will align with his radical vision for criminal justice reform. This proclamation raises eyebrows, especially given that his potential ally, NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch, has a track record of resisting the reforms he champions.

During a recent chat on the Hell Gate podcast, Mamdani brushed off concerns about Tisch’s history and insisted she would fall in line. But those who know her past records can’t help but be skeptical. Host Christopher Robbins pointedly reminded him that Tisch has consistently thwarted the very reforms that Mamdani claims he wants to implement.

Mamdani scrambled to defend his position. He pointed to Tisch’s involvement in progressive initiatives, claiming they shared a mutual goal of establishing a Department of Public Safety. Yet, it’s hard to overlook the fact that Tisch has publicly opposed key criminal justice reforms, attributing rising crime rates to policies enacted under ex-Governor Cuomo, not to her own actions.

The NYPD commissioner has backed the continuation of the notorious gang database and advocated for tough stances on low-level offenses. Robbins held Mamdani accountable, questioning whether Tisch would really change her tune. Would she honestly revert her stance to comply with his agenda if he occupied City Hall?

Mamdani confidently declared, “I think everyone will follow my lead.” But this assertion falls flat when he admits he hasn’t even spoken directly to Tisch about her role in a future administration since July. How can he expect collaboration when there’s no dialogue?

His ambitious plan to overhaul policing in the city hinges on Tisch’s support for his signature initiative. Without her cooperation, Mamdani’s lofty promises risk being just that—promises without any substantive backing. It’s a bold gamble, but New Yorkers deserve a leader who can forge a path based on clear, decisive action.